2025 Dallas Cowboys Offseason Tracker

[Dodger12]

Once upon a time guys like Doug Williams, Jeff Hostetler, Trent Dilfer and Nick Foles were Super Bowl winners too

Sorry Amigo. I think you're dead wrong on this one and you had to dig pretty for this silly reply. Manning won the SB twice and was SB MVP both times. He made some clutch throws when it mattered.

I'd take a QB #1 overall if we end up with 2 SB's, all day....every day. And then let people mock it years later. The problem with Eli is that people compare him to his brother who was a better overall QB but Eli has the rings. Give me that guy.......

 

[dbair1967]

The Giants scored 4 tds TOTAL vs the Pats in those two super bowls.

Their defense was the reason they won both those games, that and the Pats (who were resoundingly better both years) probably took them lightly. The 2011 Giants team is probably the biggest fluke champion in the history of the league. They barely had a winning record during the regular season and actually gave up more points than they scored for the season.

 

[dbair1967]

Sorry Amigo. I think you're dead wrong on this one and you had to dig pretty for this silly reply. Manning won the SB twice and was SB MVP both times. He made some clutch throws when it mattered.

I'd take a QB #1 overall if we end up with 2 SB's, all day....every day. And then let people mock it years later. The problem with Eli is that people compare him to his brother who was a better overall QB but Eli has the rings. Give me that guy.......

See post #1043

Eli was along for the ride both times. Yes he had some timely good plays, but their defense is why they won both those games (especially 2007) and the Giants offense "lit up" the Pats defense for a grand total of two tds in each game.

Eli is one of the most vastly overrated players in league history. If he had any other last name nobody would say anything about him.