Realists View

Cowboysrule122

Draft Pick
Messages
3,728
Reaction score
0
As far as change is concerned Gruden would make the most sense. He knows the defensive coaching staff and could help Romo out.

Let Gruden hire his own offensive staff. Romo sadly still needs to be on a short leash. There's no way we get rid of him right now.
 
Messages
8,660
Reaction score
0
That's just it. The fact that the game was a toss up or a predicted defeat tells you nothing's changed. Yesterday was a good test to prove to us that things are indeed different, what with Callahan in charge and two old pros directing the defense, but they flunked. As Mid lamented, this is another season of rotisserie stats and hoping you beat the hated Skins twice. In other words, empty/symbolic victories.
I agree... nothing's changed. We're still the same old Cowboys who you never know what you're gonna get. In the span of 10 minutes we can look like the best and the worst in the league.

But we all knew that this was how the season was going to go. We knew it because Jerry is still in charge. We knew it because Garrett wasn't canned. We knew it because Jerry is forcing decisions on the coaching staff he has no business making, and it leads to no accountability with this team.

We're all basically hoping this team can put shit together in spite of the coaching/front office. There's still a chance for that, but it's not likely.

But it's been that way for almost 20 years.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
Defense closed out the game last week

Defense did its job yesterday. Can't ask for anything more. I'll take that performance every week

It was luck that they got that pick 6 last week. Kc wasn't so giving and they couldn't get off the field When they knew the run was coming. Meanwhile we can't get 4 yards on a 3rd and long draw
 

jnday

UDFA
Messages
2,680
Reaction score
0
It's a process.

Why is that so hard for some of you to understand.

I'm rooting for us to lose out. I want the stadium empty by year's end. I want Garrett fired. And I want the #1 pick in the draft so we can draft Jadaveon Clownface.
This seems like a solid plan. I support a couple of years of really stinking to get better talent.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
This seems like a solid plan. I support a couple of years of really stinking to get better talent.

The only way anything changes is if you hit Jerry in the wallet. That stadium is not paid for yet. If you watched his interview you could tell he was livid and threw Garrett and Callahan under the bus. He knows what embarassing losses mean for him.

We aren't going anywhere this year. A 4-12 season will get Jerry out of the way quicker than anything else. I'll gladly take 1-15. It's exactly what he deserves.
 
Messages
3,665
Reaction score
22
I'd say 60-70% picked KC to win this game in the prediction thread. Why are you all up in arms?

Romo's drop off is what concerns me. He hasn't looked right since last season. If he's becoming what Danny White and Troy Aikman were during their final year or two with the team, much worse days are ahead.

The current status isn't good. It is disheartening to think it'll get much worse over the next several seasons before it gets better.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
3
Damn, guys, it's been 2 games and a half of shoddy Romo performance. Learn to chill, bros.
 

cmd34(work)

Draft Pick
Messages
4,342
Reaction score
0
I know I'll sound like I'm defending Romo here but investing a high draft pick on a QB pays off long term but has us running in place for now. The new QB will have the same unimaginative playcalling, the same weak interior OL, and a defense that can't stop the run when everyone knows it's coming.

Romo is definitely off, he's hesitating, and he could not throw that out or corner pattern to save his life yesterday.
 
Messages
2,329
Reaction score
11
That game may have a rock bottom effect and cause some desperation invention. There is still a real lack of use of the talent and has been for years mainly because the offense is made up of a bunch of possible options rather than intentional strategies to free up or isolate the path of one player.

For example, Steve Young was commenting on the Niners last year saying that they were not running the ball all that often, as much as they were putting a lot of thought into the designs of the running plays. Yesterday, the Chiefs did the same and despite the Dallas defense playing pretty well, the Chiefs had the Cowboys on their heels and chasing rather than attacking.

When Dez is having to carry the whole hope of the team despite having Witten, Hanna, Murray, Miles, and Harris, there is something going wrong with the engineering of the plays (not the execution). The team doesn't have an offensive identity problem, it has a severely outdated design that is just wasting its opportunities.
My primary concern is this: Dez, Miles, Witten, and Harris all have the most mastery they have ever had of the playbook. In this offseason, Dez, Harris and Miles all were complimented on their route running. So it appears that despite running their routes the best that they ever have and understanding the playbook the best that they ever have, they are less open than they have ever been.
How is that?
It's fascinating that the WRs can be regarded as being the best they have been at running the scheme and yet the worse at applying the scheme to beating a defense. If Miles runs a crisp route, accelerates in and out of cuts exactly where he is supposed to be for what the defense is showing, it's only effective if the defense can't defend or cover it. With exception to Dez a few times yesterday, the Chiefs went right to the locations they knew Dallas would go with their pass plays. The running plays were far too few to accomplish anything.

Here are my solutions to cure what ails the Garrett delirium.

1. Need more actual lateral running plays with end arounds, pitches, and especially, pulling/trapping plays. They seem to fake those plays a lot but the fakes are only effective if the defense is concerned that Dallas will run the wide play. Remember a few years ago when Jason would call for a play-action play when Dallas was at 3rd and 20 from their own 15. That was just silly (and a little embarrassing).
2. Romo needs to move. He needs to intentionally bootleg a few times, roll out, stretch play, and shuttle the ball quickly.
3. Dunbar and Murray need to be in the same backfield.
4. Put more analysis into how the defense is trying to stop the run and then call plays to counter them. Garrett has been doing this type of experimentation for years with the pass offense, but he never stopped calling pass plays when Romo was shut down game after game in the first quarter. Instead, he was analyzing what the defense was doing to figure out how the pass plays would work later. He doesn't give the same attention to the run. Josh McDaniel is accused of doing the same thing with the Patriots: might get 2 yards on a first down run and does not run again in the series. Frank Gore has had 20 carry games where he averaged 2.7 yards per game.
5. Speaking of the Patriots, they might be desperate for a WR like Miles right now....
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
5. Speaking of the Patriots, they might be desperate for a WR like Miles right now....
Good post but this caught my eye because I was thinking the exact same thing watching them play Thursday night.

How much do they wish they hadn't traded down with us in 2010 and had stayed and taken Dez themselves?
 
Messages
2,329
Reaction score
11
Good post but this caught my eye because I was thinking the exact same thing watching them play Thursday night.

How much do they wish they hadn't traded down with us in 2010 and had stayed and taken Dez themselves?
I had to drive from New York to New Hampshire and back today so I listened to a lot of Patriots sports radio. From all of the fans to the talk show hosts, these were the most common topics: Amendola not enough even when healthy, Edelman and the others ("Dropson??") cannot carry the offense when Amendola is out, Adam Schefter said that Josh McDaniels gives up on the run too soon, and with Gronkowski coming back the offense is still in need of WR help.
 

junk

UDFA
Messages
2,719
Reaction score
0
During the season, I never really get too worked up over a loss. I expected them to drop one of these early ones (I thought maybe the Rams). Dallas always loses a couple they should win and win a couple they shouldn't. End of the day, 8-8 range although, honestly, that might get them in the playoffs this year. NFC East is looking weak.

Garrett - I'm just not seeing much there, at least as an OC or a designer of an offense. Bring in someone fresh and new.
 
Top Bottom