dbair1967
Administrator
- Messages
- 75,017
- Reaction score
- 21,759
Ho hum, another game and another franchise all-time worst defensive performance ever. I've run out of descriptive terms for what we see and can't think of anymore. It's just pure comedy and keystone cops-esque every damn week with these guys. This is 3 consecutive seasons of pure garbage defense. 4 of 7 if you go back to McCarthy's first yr in 2020. Defense that is just unexplainably bad. They've changed coaches. They've changed schemes. They've turned over the defensive roster multiple times. They've allocated high picks to defensive help. They've traded for proven guys. They've signed free agents. And STILL it's not even remotely competitive. I've come to the conclusion that they play defense the way they do almost 100% because of the way the Jones' run the program. They're soft. They lack a real plan. They make the same mistakes over and over. No attention to detail. No awareness. Jones may not say it out loud, but he basically tells the organization "I don't care about stopping the other team as long as we have interesting games and interesting players". And the team plays that way. It's a culture thing, and it's the main reason this franchise is a perennial loser now.
1) Amigo Dodger can hate me if he wants, but I don't blame Prescott much for the loss yesterday, and I don't agree with him that all our scoring and "success" came just during "garbage time v prevent defense" either. There was nothing "prevent" with how the Niners were calling their defenses until the last couple plays of the game. I was super mad at Prescott about the pick when it happened but replay clearly shows he could NOT have ran for the first down and actually got jacked up on the throw anyway (late). I also give him some props for completely giving himself up on the effort to make the 2pt play at the end. He had 4-6 good throws dropped and was under pretty consistent pressure, watched his team score 40 pts and still seem hopeless to have a chance to win the game. Plenty of stuff to criticize him for over the years (and this season) but yesterday isn't one of them. Now this is not to say anything has changed for me about the QB of the future, I think a relatively high pick has to be used on it next yr and depending on who they get, maybe 2028 as well. They've got to start moving forward with "the next guy" but yesterday was not on 4 IMO.
2) Speaking of the 2pt play, nobody is going to convince me that going for 2 when down 14 pts is the right thing to do. If you have analytics people saying to do it, then they need to be fired and analytics shouldn't be considered in your decision making ever again. It makes ZERO fucking sense to do it there. Kick the fucking extra point to make it a 7pt game and then IF you score again and it's near the end of the game THEN make the call to try and win it by going for 2 the 2nd time. If you do it the first time and don't make it then you are stuck HAVING to convert the 2nd time just to tie. It's mind numbingly stupid but par for the course for the worst HC in the league.
3) Von Miller got 28 snaps yesterday. He made one tackle and was credited with zero pressures or QB knockdowns. It makes zero sense for this guy to even be on the team. Should have been released over a month ago, maybe even just a couple weeks into the season when it was obvious he had zero gas left in the tank. But this is a poorly run franchise and this is how a poorly run franchise operates. If you want him in the facility for his knowledge and leadership fine, make him a fucking assistant or a consultant. Don't waste a roster spot and valuable snaps on a guy that can't play.
4) We get nothing out of the TE position at all. Upgrading the spot with someone capable has to be a priority for next yr. Whether it's the draft or free agency it doesn't matter, but they need at least something adequate there.
5) Every yr we hear "we are going to give Hunter Luepke a bigger role" and every yr they do nothing different and he is just a wasted roster spot. But when I watch him run the ball and catch it, it's obvious he has skill that could really help this team. Imagine a coach like Kyle Shanahan with this guy. He'd be getting multiple touches every week and making teams pay for all the "junk" coverages they play us with because of Lamb/Pickens. He has great hands and some really nice athletic ability (in fact FAR more athletic than any of the stiffs we have playing TE now). His college tape shows highlight reel catch and run over and over. He is also physical with some wiggle in the run game. Just a waste.
6) We clearly have SOME pieces for this defense, and it's being wasted by a complete moron at DC. Quinnen Williams plays a 5T type role in a 3 man front and he is still dominating games. Yesterday he had 10 f'in tackles by himself. He had another sack and multiple pressures, another TFL. Then nearly had one of the all-time great forced fumble efforts at the end of the game that would have given the Cowboys a real chance at a miracle win. Dude is having an awesome yr, and it's all for naught. Joey Porter was also a great acquisition. Yeah he needs to get and stay healthy, but when he is out there he erases people.
7) I don't have any delusions that officials cost us the game yesterday (and the penalty scoreboard says the Niners had more than twice as many penalties as us and nearly triple the penalty yards. But they got away with a lot of stuff in the secondary and on their OL and almost none of that was called. I also find it amazing that we are always "just short" and this <> close to the first down, but not there and see highly questionable spots over and over and over. Yet the other team always gets the spot it seems. There were definitely two or three plays where we seemed to get the shaft on the spots again yesterday (as seemingly happens every week).
8) Our run game wasn't terrible yesterday against a solid Niner defense (esp in the first half) but to compare, the Niners got 216 yds on 29 carries and 3 rushing tds (obviously aided by the laughably horrible 70 yd reverse by Samuel). But even taking that away completely they still rushed for 146 yds on 28 carries ((5.2 yds a pop) and two tds. 4 different Niner players had rushes over 12 yards. On the flipside, we got 96 yds on 24 carries (4.0 yds per carry) again not bad, but no RB (or QB) had a rush over 9 yds. Nobody in the league is better than Kyle Shanahan at scheming a great run game with explosive plays. The only two who are close are probably Ben Johnson in Chicago and Joe Brady with Buffalo. Common theme here? Not one of them was interviewed (or even called) by these fucking retard Jones clowns for a job here.
We have two very winnable home games against two bad teams coming up, which puts us in an almost identical spot as last yr when we won 3 straight to get to 6-5-1 on Thanksgiving only to then finish 1-4 in December. If we win against bad Titan and Eagles teams, we'd be 6-6 and then go into a December schedule where we'll probably go 1-4 or 0-5. I don't see any way possible the Jonestards can justify bringing Schottenheimer and Parker back after such a dumpster fire season, but we all thought the same things for years under Garrett and even though McCarthy had to be gone after that abortion of a loss to GB in the postseason, which made it 3 straight years of postseason flops.
1) Amigo Dodger can hate me if he wants, but I don't blame Prescott much for the loss yesterday, and I don't agree with him that all our scoring and "success" came just during "garbage time v prevent defense" either. There was nothing "prevent" with how the Niners were calling their defenses until the last couple plays of the game. I was super mad at Prescott about the pick when it happened but replay clearly shows he could NOT have ran for the first down and actually got jacked up on the throw anyway (late). I also give him some props for completely giving himself up on the effort to make the 2pt play at the end. He had 4-6 good throws dropped and was under pretty consistent pressure, watched his team score 40 pts and still seem hopeless to have a chance to win the game. Plenty of stuff to criticize him for over the years (and this season) but yesterday isn't one of them. Now this is not to say anything has changed for me about the QB of the future, I think a relatively high pick has to be used on it next yr and depending on who they get, maybe 2028 as well. They've got to start moving forward with "the next guy" but yesterday was not on 4 IMO.
2) Speaking of the 2pt play, nobody is going to convince me that going for 2 when down 14 pts is the right thing to do. If you have analytics people saying to do it, then they need to be fired and analytics shouldn't be considered in your decision making ever again. It makes ZERO fucking sense to do it there. Kick the fucking extra point to make it a 7pt game and then IF you score again and it's near the end of the game THEN make the call to try and win it by going for 2 the 2nd time. If you do it the first time and don't make it then you are stuck HAVING to convert the 2nd time just to tie. It's mind numbingly stupid but par for the course for the worst HC in the league.
3) Von Miller got 28 snaps yesterday. He made one tackle and was credited with zero pressures or QB knockdowns. It makes zero sense for this guy to even be on the team. Should have been released over a month ago, maybe even just a couple weeks into the season when it was obvious he had zero gas left in the tank. But this is a poorly run franchise and this is how a poorly run franchise operates. If you want him in the facility for his knowledge and leadership fine, make him a fucking assistant or a consultant. Don't waste a roster spot and valuable snaps on a guy that can't play.
4) We get nothing out of the TE position at all. Upgrading the spot with someone capable has to be a priority for next yr. Whether it's the draft or free agency it doesn't matter, but they need at least something adequate there.
5) Every yr we hear "we are going to give Hunter Luepke a bigger role" and every yr they do nothing different and he is just a wasted roster spot. But when I watch him run the ball and catch it, it's obvious he has skill that could really help this team. Imagine a coach like Kyle Shanahan with this guy. He'd be getting multiple touches every week and making teams pay for all the "junk" coverages they play us with because of Lamb/Pickens. He has great hands and some really nice athletic ability (in fact FAR more athletic than any of the stiffs we have playing TE now). His college tape shows highlight reel catch and run over and over. He is also physical with some wiggle in the run game. Just a waste.
6) We clearly have SOME pieces for this defense, and it's being wasted by a complete moron at DC. Quinnen Williams plays a 5T type role in a 3 man front and he is still dominating games. Yesterday he had 10 f'in tackles by himself. He had another sack and multiple pressures, another TFL. Then nearly had one of the all-time great forced fumble efforts at the end of the game that would have given the Cowboys a real chance at a miracle win. Dude is having an awesome yr, and it's all for naught. Joey Porter was also a great acquisition. Yeah he needs to get and stay healthy, but when he is out there he erases people.
7) I don't have any delusions that officials cost us the game yesterday (and the penalty scoreboard says the Niners had more than twice as many penalties as us and nearly triple the penalty yards. But they got away with a lot of stuff in the secondary and on their OL and almost none of that was called. I also find it amazing that we are always "just short" and this <> close to the first down, but not there and see highly questionable spots over and over and over. Yet the other team always gets the spot it seems. There were definitely two or three plays where we seemed to get the shaft on the spots again yesterday (as seemingly happens every week).
8) Our run game wasn't terrible yesterday against a solid Niner defense (esp in the first half) but to compare, the Niners got 216 yds on 29 carries and 3 rushing tds (obviously aided by the laughably horrible 70 yd reverse by Samuel). But even taking that away completely they still rushed for 146 yds on 28 carries ((5.2 yds a pop) and two tds. 4 different Niner players had rushes over 12 yards. On the flipside, we got 96 yds on 24 carries (4.0 yds per carry) again not bad, but no RB (or QB) had a rush over 9 yds. Nobody in the league is better than Kyle Shanahan at scheming a great run game with explosive plays. The only two who are close are probably Ben Johnson in Chicago and Joe Brady with Buffalo. Common theme here? Not one of them was interviewed (or even called) by these fucking retard Jones clowns for a job here.
We have two very winnable home games against two bad teams coming up, which puts us in an almost identical spot as last yr when we won 3 straight to get to 6-5-1 on Thanksgiving only to then finish 1-4 in December. If we win against bad Titan and Eagles teams, we'd be 6-6 and then go into a December schedule where we'll probably go 1-4 or 0-5. I don't see any way possible the Jonestards can justify bringing Schottenheimer and Parker back after such a dumpster fire season, but we all thought the same things for years under Garrett and even though McCarthy had to be gone after that abortion of a loss to GB in the postseason, which made it 3 straight years of postseason flops.