A way out of this (O Line) mess

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
126
As I always do when it appears the season will go down in flames, I started looking towards the future. I know we just signed Doug Free, Nate Livings, Mackenzy Bernadeau, Jermey Parnell, and Ryan Cook to contract extensions but they are showing me they are clearly not solutions. Parnell is young and raw but has shown nothing so far (in games) and Cook has some versatility so he could stick as a reserve. David Arkin can’t seem to crack the line up even when we are desperate. Phil Costa is awful despite the team’s obsession with him and Kevin Kowalski isn’t good enough (when healthy) to beat out Costa. If this core group of Romo, Witten, and Austin are going to have any chance, the offensive line must be fixed.

Doug Free was given a 4 yr extension in 2011 worth $32M, $17M guaranteed. His 2013 salary cap should he return next year would be $11,175,000. If we cut him this off-season, the cap hit would be $8,350,000. Releasing him actually creates $2,825,000 in cap room as well as saving the Cowboys $7M in actual salary paid out next year.
(-$2,825,000)

Mackenzy Bernadeausigned a 4 yr deal worth $11M this off-season. His 2013 cap number would be $2,562,500. If released, the hit would be $2,437,500, which would save $125,000.
(-$125,000)

Nate Livings signed a 5 yr deal worth $18.7M with a $3.5M signing bonus. His 2013 cap number would be $2.4M. If released, the hit would be $2.8. So, in his case it’s “cheaper to keep her” and since he’s performed better than the rest of this bunch, we might be okay with this. If released after the 2013 season, we would gain $2M in cap room, so at worse, it would be 1 more year of Livings. Still if you wanted to clean house, cutting him takes up an additional $400,000.
(+$400,000)

Ryan Cook signed a 2 yr extension worth $2.1M. His 2013 cap number is $1.25M. Releasing him creates $1.1M in cap room. I don’t mind him since he can play all 5 OL spots but again going with the cleaning house mentality..
(-$1,100,000)

Jermey Parnell – 3 yr $4,062,000. 2013 Cap Number = $1,356,421. Cap hit if released = $666,666 (not making that up). Savings = $689,755.
(-$689,755).

David Arkin – 4 yr $2,540,000. 2013 Cap number = $680,000. Cap hit if released = $250,000. Savings = $430,000.
(-$430,000)

Derrick Dockery is under a 1 year deal and hopefully is not part of the 2013 plan. Who knows with this staff.

Phil Costa is a restricted free agent. A tender next year would be around $1 M (possibly more). We don’t gain anything by letting him walk but keeping him costs that additional $1M.

Kevin Kowalski – 3 yr $1,395,000. I can’t find the specifics on his signing bonus but releasing him would create $555,000 in cap room.
(-$555,000)

No team is going to release 9 out of 10 Offensive Linemen in 1 season, although that would send a powerful message to underachievers on this team. I just wrote this to show we do have options. Let’s say we kept Tyron Smith (numbers not included since there is no way the team would consider releasing him), Nate Livings, and Ryan Cook meaning we have to go out and sign, draft, or trade for 6 new offensive linemen. Releasing the other linemen would create $4,624,755 in additional cap room. Yes, I know that creates “dead money” for a year but you have to look at like this. One, that money (signing bonuses) has already been spent. Two, would you want to keep paying this cast of underachievers? Keeping the 6 players I suggested cutting would take up over $17M in cap space. That’s not counting any 2013 roster bonuses they may have written into their contracts.

Again, I don’t really think we would let this many players from one unit go in a single off-season. I just know now that we aren’t stuck with them.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
10
That Doug Free contract is one of the most ridiculous contracts we've shelled out in a long time. And that's saying something.

11 million next year?
 

Sheik

All-Pro
Messages
24,809
Reaction score
15
I thought the Douglas Free contract was cap friendly?

wtf happened, guys?
 

Sheik

All-Pro
Messages
24,809
Reaction score
15
Bill Callahan is one of the best coaches on the planet.

thats the solution, per Jerry.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
126
I thought the Douglas Free contract was cap friendly?

wtf happened, guys?

It was/is last year and this. Next year his base jumps up to $7 million and his cap number jumps to $11.175M. His base this year is only $1.2M and his cap number is $5.375M. Huge jump next year.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
126
I'm talking about the 3-4 replacements who will also suck

Got you. Hopefully, we draft Barrett Jones and some depth in the later rounds. After signing some free agents like Jake Long or Brandon Albert (expensive) and/or Eben Britton, Andy Levitre, Antone Caldwell (less espensive).

The biggest problem with my scenario is that OL doesn't appear to be deep in free agency or the draft. The key is having new eyes targeting the replacements. I don't know what we saw in Bernadeau, Livings, and Parnell that made us think throwing money at them was a good idea.
 

Theebs

Quality Starter
Messages
8,534
Reaction score
0
nice.

No way any of this happens.

Guys may get benched but released, not with the jones family in charge.

after what happened in 06 with the bad free agents and the roy williams nonsense I doubt he ever eats money on free agents again
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
Got you. Hopefully, we draft Barrett Jones and some depth in the later rounds. After signing some free agents like Jake Long or Brandon Albert (expensive) and/or Eben Britton, Andy Levitre, Antone Caldwell (less espensive).

The biggest problem with my scenario is that OL doesn't appear to be deep in free agency or the draft. The key is having new eyes targeting the replacements. I don't know what we saw in Bernadeau, Livings, and Parnell that made us think throwing money at them was a good idea.

I think I heard ebon britton has been awful.


I want them to just go balls out on 2 spots. Overpay the next nicks and don't worry about that spot. Draft chance warmack if he's the best LOS player available.

You can nickel and dime on 1 spot but 3 has been disastrous. It's just too juicy for D coordinators to scheme against

I'd be a hypocrite to say we should re-sign dez if it precludes a stud linemen. (although dez should come cheaper than we think all things considered).

I'd even consider trading witten for a comparable talent. Without major changes this core will just wither away and ride off Into the sunset anyway.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
8
It was/is last year and this. Next year his base jumps up to $7 million and his cap number jumps to $11.175M. His base this year is only $1.2M and his cap number is $5.375M. Huge jump next year.

Don't these backloaded contracts make it easier to cut a player once their salary jumps exponentially?
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
8
This whole thing sucks. So instead of getting 5 guys together to stick and grow cohesively as a unit, we are looking at rebuilding the whole line again because any new guy we bring in, either has to have come from a blocking scheme near mirror image of the one we run, or have played for Bill Callahan before. But still, getting 3 new guys in, there's going to be a small chance of that happening.

We're looking at 3 years of inconsistent line play if we do what you propose, which is why I don't see much turnover on the line as regards to jettisoning players. I think we devote some serious resources to the line, but the cast of characters there will largely remain the same IMO
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
You're overrating the cohesion factor. Right now We just have bad athletes who aren't as strong or quick as their opponents.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
8
You're overrating the cohesion factor. Right now We just have bad athletes who aren't as strong or quick as their opponents.

Not just cohesion playing next to each other, but in the schematic way of things. You can't just bring in 3 new players and say, "Go get them!".

That, more than anything, is why Oline is so important. It's not merely the quality of the players, but the comfort level that they have playing in it that counts too.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
With the exotic defenses these days it does come down to that sometimes. Not that we'd run a straight zone scheme but when a D throws a NASCAR package at you or drops 2 DT's into coverage it becomes much more simplified once the ball is snapped . You have to be able to adjust. That to me is coaching way more than cohesion.

3 years? Fuck outta here
 
Top Bottom