sbk92
2
- Messages
- 12,134
- Reaction score
- 6
Newton's struggles lead QB news
Todd McShay, Steve Muench and Kevin Weidl
Scouts Inc.
More questions regarding the top quarterbacks in this year's draft class need to be answered than in most years. How they come off the board will have little to do with how they performed inside Lucas Oil Stadium on Sunday, but there was still valuable scouting formation to be taken from the workout sessions.
For starters, the 2011 class is one of the most competitive, most athletic and fastest groups to come through Indianapolis in several years. The only prospect who elected not to throw was Missouri's Blaine Gabbert, and even he elected to participate in the running and jumping portions of the workout. In the end, seven quarterbacks ran the 40-yard dash in 4.65 seconds or faster.
The most anticipated workout of the entire combine was that of Auburn's Cam Newton, who tied for the best broad jump among quarterbacks and finished in the top five in the vertical jump and 40-yard dash. Things didn't go as well for Newton during passing drills, though.
Newton showed very good touch on vertical throws and was accurate for the most part on post-corner routes. He was far too erratic on short-to-intermediate throws, though, failing to get back in his drops quickly enough and struggling with timing. Newton appeared to become frustrated figuring out when to get the ball out, and he failed to throw to spots as receivers were breaking.
Some of that can be chalked up to throwing to unfamiliar receivers and struggling to adjust to the differences in speed from one receiver to the next, but that issue can't be blamed for the three out routes Newton completely sailed over the heads of receivers.
Newton has clearly worked on his footwork and improving his balance when transferring his weight from back to front, and we expect to see more consistent drops and anticipation when he throws to his own receivers in a scripted throwing session at Auburn's March 8 pro day. But even if he performs well in that workout, where Newton comes off the board -- likely among the top 12 overall picks -- will have much more to do with how he interviews and what teams find out as they investigate his character and mental makeup.
We've heard wide-ranging opinions on Newton's intangibles while talking to NFL types this week in Indianapolis, but overall, he does not appear to be helping his cause much.
Gabbert's athleticism shines
Veteran scouts grumbled about Gabbert's decision not to throw, but it will have no effect on his draft stock. Remember, eight of the past 12 quarterbacks drafted in the first round have opted out of combine passing drills.
The rest of the workout went well for Gabbert, who ran the 40 in 4.62 seconds and posted a 10-foot broad jump. Speed, mobility and athleticism are among the least important traits when evaluating a quarterback, but Gabbert is clearly in the upper echelon in those categories and an underrated athlete for a 6-foot-4, 234-pound prospect. He will throw for scouts March 17 at Missouri's pro day.
Mallett, Ponder throw well
Ryan Mallett (Arkansas) and Christian Ponder turned in the best passing performances of the day. Mallett has the strongest arm in the class, and although his delivery looks smooth and easy, the ball explodes out of his hand. He threw with velocity but also showed good touch and anticipation on timing throws.
Ponder is continuing to build momentum after a strong Senior Bowl week and is shaking off the frustration of an injury-riddled senior season. His accuracy on quick-hitting passes and out routes was impressive, and he did the best job of any quarterback leading receivers on fade routes. Keep in mind, though, that the combine did not test Ponder's weakness in terms of maintaining accuracy when dealing with pressure.
Taylor shows athleticism, struggles while passing
Virginia Tech's Tyrod Taylor had the fastest 40 time among quarterbacks at 4.51 seconds and tied for the best broad jump at 10-foot-6, but he looked timid throwing the ball and had one of the most underwhelming passing performances of the day.
Taylor seemed nervous and appeared to aim the ball rather than driving through and letting it fly. He is determined to be a quarterback in the NFL, but the team that drafts Taylor is likely to put him in a versatile role while he develops. He has the build (6 feet, 217 pounds) and athleticism to transition to wide receiver. His 40 time would have ranked in the top third among wide receivers, and his broad jump would have been ninth among wideouts.
Todd McShay, Steve Muench and Kevin Weidl
Scouts Inc.
More questions regarding the top quarterbacks in this year's draft class need to be answered than in most years. How they come off the board will have little to do with how they performed inside Lucas Oil Stadium on Sunday, but there was still valuable scouting formation to be taken from the workout sessions.
For starters, the 2011 class is one of the most competitive, most athletic and fastest groups to come through Indianapolis in several years. The only prospect who elected not to throw was Missouri's Blaine Gabbert, and even he elected to participate in the running and jumping portions of the workout. In the end, seven quarterbacks ran the 40-yard dash in 4.65 seconds or faster.
The most anticipated workout of the entire combine was that of Auburn's Cam Newton, who tied for the best broad jump among quarterbacks and finished in the top five in the vertical jump and 40-yard dash. Things didn't go as well for Newton during passing drills, though.
Newton showed very good touch on vertical throws and was accurate for the most part on post-corner routes. He was far too erratic on short-to-intermediate throws, though, failing to get back in his drops quickly enough and struggling with timing. Newton appeared to become frustrated figuring out when to get the ball out, and he failed to throw to spots as receivers were breaking.
Some of that can be chalked up to throwing to unfamiliar receivers and struggling to adjust to the differences in speed from one receiver to the next, but that issue can't be blamed for the three out routes Newton completely sailed over the heads of receivers.
Newton has clearly worked on his footwork and improving his balance when transferring his weight from back to front, and we expect to see more consistent drops and anticipation when he throws to his own receivers in a scripted throwing session at Auburn's March 8 pro day. But even if he performs well in that workout, where Newton comes off the board -- likely among the top 12 overall picks -- will have much more to do with how he interviews and what teams find out as they investigate his character and mental makeup.
We've heard wide-ranging opinions on Newton's intangibles while talking to NFL types this week in Indianapolis, but overall, he does not appear to be helping his cause much.
Gabbert's athleticism shines
Veteran scouts grumbled about Gabbert's decision not to throw, but it will have no effect on his draft stock. Remember, eight of the past 12 quarterbacks drafted in the first round have opted out of combine passing drills.
The rest of the workout went well for Gabbert, who ran the 40 in 4.62 seconds and posted a 10-foot broad jump. Speed, mobility and athleticism are among the least important traits when evaluating a quarterback, but Gabbert is clearly in the upper echelon in those categories and an underrated athlete for a 6-foot-4, 234-pound prospect. He will throw for scouts March 17 at Missouri's pro day.
Mallett, Ponder throw well
Ryan Mallett (Arkansas) and Christian Ponder turned in the best passing performances of the day. Mallett has the strongest arm in the class, and although his delivery looks smooth and easy, the ball explodes out of his hand. He threw with velocity but also showed good touch and anticipation on timing throws.
Ponder is continuing to build momentum after a strong Senior Bowl week and is shaking off the frustration of an injury-riddled senior season. His accuracy on quick-hitting passes and out routes was impressive, and he did the best job of any quarterback leading receivers on fade routes. Keep in mind, though, that the combine did not test Ponder's weakness in terms of maintaining accuracy when dealing with pressure.
Taylor shows athleticism, struggles while passing
Virginia Tech's Tyrod Taylor had the fastest 40 time among quarterbacks at 4.51 seconds and tied for the best broad jump at 10-foot-6, but he looked timid throwing the ball and had one of the most underwhelming passing performances of the day.
Taylor seemed nervous and appeared to aim the ball rather than driving through and letting it fly. He is determined to be a quarterback in the NFL, but the team that drafts Taylor is likely to put him in a versatile role while he develops. He has the build (6 feet, 217 pounds) and athleticism to transition to wide receiver. His 40 time would have ranked in the top third among wide receivers, and his broad jump would have been ninth among wideouts.