Simple Yes or No vote: Bill Bates for the Cowboys Ring of Honor


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
No, but does it have to be a white comparison? How good was he for his position league-wide?
It doesn't, but Tasker was a similar special teams demon who didn't have a real position. Actually as I remember Tasker was a decent 4th-5th WR, better than Bates anyway.

Bates sucked as a safety. He just wasn't athletic enough, though he was crazy and reckless enough to be good running down and hitting people. Can't really think of a huge special teams star now... Who would that be?
 

Doomsday

High Plains Drifter
Messages
21,577
Reaction score
4,000
so he was "THE embodiment of the Cowboys" but not a legend?
If Bill Bates isn't THE embodiment of the Cowboys, who is? I put him right up there with Bob Lilly as far as off the field character goes. He is a honorable man and always was.

You already said you wouldn't have a problem with Bates in the RoH and I never called him a "Legend" although he has won several Legends awards including the "Tom Landry Legend" award back in 2011.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
It doesn't, but Tasker was a similar special teams demon who didn't have a real position. Actually as I remember Tasker was a decent 4th-5th WR, better than Bates anyway.

Bates sucked as a safety. He just wasn't athletic enough, though he was crazy and reckless enough to be good running down and hitting people. Can't really think of a huge special teams star now... Who would that be?


Idk im waiting for you to tell me!
 

Doomsday

High Plains Drifter
Messages
21,577
Reaction score
4,000
Bates sucked as a safety. He just wasn't athletic enough, though he was crazy and reckless enough to be good running down and hitting people.
He had a knack for being in the right place at the right time, exactly when you needed him. If he sucked as a safety, Jimmy wouldn't be playing him as a safety! You know more than Jimmy Johnson and Tom Landry?
 

Doomsday

High Plains Drifter
Messages
21,577
Reaction score
4,000
Jimmy Johnson owes his first playoff win to a timely, game sealing Bill Bates pick.
 

Iamtdg

2
Messages
5,614
Reaction score
0
We are talking about RoH credentials here and Bates is IN the top ten for Dallas Cowboys safeties.

You keep saying that, but that doesn't buy him a ticket into the ROH. Tony Hill is is top 5, IMO, and he's not in, and he contributed a helluva lot more than Bates did.
 

bbgun

Administrator
Messages
15,109
Reaction score
2,246
If Bill Bates isn't THE embodiment of the Cowboys, who is? I put him right up there with Bob Lilly as far as off the field character goes. He is a honorable man and always was.

You already said you wouldn't have a problem with Bates in the RoH and I never called him a "Legend" although he has won several Legends awards including the "Tom Landry Legend" award back in 2011.

so you would have disagreed with Hos when he called him the "legendary Bill Bates," right?
 

Iamtdg

2
Messages
5,614
Reaction score
0
If Bill Bates isn't THE embodiment of the Cowboys, who is? I put him right up there with Bob Lilly as far as off the field character goes. He is a honorable man and always was.

You already said you wouldn't have a problem with Bates in the RoH and I never called him a "Legend" although he has won several Legends awards including the "Tom Landry Legend" award back in 2011.

Roger Staubach
Randy White
Michael Irvin
Troy Aikman
Emmitt Smith
Bob Lily
Larry Allen
Lee Roy Jordan

I can name the rest of the ROH of you would like.
 

Doomsday

High Plains Drifter
Messages
21,577
Reaction score
4,000
so you would have disagreed with Hos when he called him the "legendary Bill Bates," right?
I didn't and wouldn't use that terminology. But I wouldn't pitch a fit about someone using it either.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
Bates wasn't nearly as good as Ken Hamlin as a safety. He wasn't nearly as good as Randy Hughes, though I don't really remember him.

That's how great he was.
 
Top Bottom