Messages
4,604
Reaction score
0
NFLPA threatens “appropriate action” over replacement officials
Posted by Mike Florio on September 9, 2012, 7:49 PM EDT

Jay Glazer of FOX reported earlier today that the NFLPA expressed to the league in writing its concerns regarding the replacement officials. We have now obtained the writing.

In a September 5, 2012 letter from NFLPA general counsel Tom DePaso to NFL general counsel Jeff Pash, DePaso requests biographies of all replacement officials, including their names, ages, and experience.

“Should it be evident that the replacement officials are under-qualified or inexperienced, we reserve the right to assert that utilizing replacement officials jeopardizes the health and safety of our members and to take appropriate action to protect our members,” DePaso wrote. “In addition, our players request that the locked-out officials immediately be allowed to return to work for this weekends’ games to ensure the players’ health and safety is protected until you reach a new agreement with them.”

DePaso also called the performance of the replacement officials “sub-par” during the preseason, “far below the standard set by the members of the Referees Association.” He likewise expressed concern regarding the ability of the replacements to adjust to the “increased competition, speed and level of play” in the regular season.

On the surface, the replacements have stepped up. They look the part and sound the part, with no obvious blunders. But that doesn’t mean they’re making all the calls that the regular officials would make.

And so it’s unlikely the NFLPA will go away quietly. The question remains when the words will become action, and why action hasn’t already been taken.

UPDATE 7:55 p.m. ET: NFL spokesman Greg Aiello says that Pash responded to the letter, agreed to provide the information, and said there is no evidence that the replacement officials are jeopardizing player safety.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
55,013
Reaction score
6,150
sub par would be putting it kindly IMO...these guys are horrible, but not because of player safety
 

63echo

2
Messages
909
Reaction score
0
As image conscious as the league is, I can't believe they're allowing this embarrassment to continue. It was one thing to have this circus on the field during preseason, but it's another thing entirely to have them ruling over regular season games and it needs to stop before it costs anyone a game.
 
Messages
4,604
Reaction score
0
Kind of old, but still relevant...

NFL making wrong call on this one
UPDATED AUG 7, 2012 4:40 PM ET

It was big news Monday that Shannon Eastin will become the first female official to work an NFL game on Thursday night in San Diego. This is a huge milestone. History will be made.

Well, there better be a big asterisk by her name, because Eastin does not deserve this honor. Something this big should go to a woman who earned the right — and that is not Eastin.

I feel very badly for Sarah Thomas, an official in Conference USA who deserves to carry the torch. She has gone through the lengthy, requisite training process required of future NFL officials and has been working NCAA Division I college football since 2007.

Eastin, as news reports have stated, has been working in the Football Championship Subdivision since 2008.

Thomas has worked five seasons of Division I football (now called Football Bowl Subdivision). Eastin has worked none.

Thomas has worked two bowl games, the 2009 Little Caesars Pizza Bowl and the 2011 Pinstripe Bowl, putting her in elite company among NCAA officials. She also worked the 2010 United Football League Championship game.

Eastin, who will take the field at Qualcomm Stadium when the San Diego Chargers play host to the Green Bay Packers, has worked no bowl games.

Thomas, because of her experience, track record and great potential, has been selected by the NFL as a finalist to become an NFL official. That means, by default, she is among the NFL officials currently locked out by the league due to the ongoing dispute over a new collective bargaining agreement between the two sides.

And sadly, that also means that Thomas, who has gone through the NFL’s interview process and all the background checks necessary to be on track to become a league official, will not get her opportunity to make history.

Instead, Eastin, who is not an NFL finalist and likely won't be, steps in front of Thomas to seize this tremendous opportunity.

It is an absolute shame that Eastin will be identified as the first female official to work an NFL game. If I were her, I would step aside and leave this huge milestone to Thomas, who truly deserves to be the trailblazer.

This is just part of this madness we call "replacement officials." They are now taking the field in the NFL preseason, as the labor impasse between the league and its trained officials continues with no end in sight.

Last Sunday’s Pro Football Hall of Fame game between the Saints and the Cardinals was refereed by a guy named Craig Ochoa. He was touted as a BCS official. Well, that is not the case.

He never officiated in the Big 10 and, as a matter of fact, was released from the Lingerie Football League midway through last season.

Can we please get this thing settled?
 
Top Bottom