Todd McShay Invitational Report Card

Todd McShay · Mar 1, 2012

The grading scale used
A+ ....7.90 and up
A ......7.55 - 7.89
A- .....7.30 - 7.54
B+ ....7.10 - 7.29
B ......6.60 - 7.09
B- .....6.40 - 6.59
C+ ....6.20 - 6.39
C ......6.10 - 6.19
C- ....6.00 - 6.09
D+ ....5.90 - 5.99
D ......5.70 - 5.89
D- ....5.45 - 5.69
F ......5.44 and lower

-

Congrats to the First Annual Todd McShay Invitational Champion: Cmd34
Biggest steal was: Harrison Smith, S, Notre Dame (carphalen515)

Biggest reach was: Janoris Jenkins, CB, Buccaneers (Roythebagofdicks)
-

Grades

Browns (cmd34)

Average: 7.84
Grade: A

Rams (DoomsdayDefense)
Average: 7.65
Grade: A

Jets (carphalen5150)
Average: 7.59
Grade: A

Packers (marionbarberthe4th)
Average: 7.49
Grade: A-

Seahawk (nevercatch22)
Average: 7.44
Grade: A-

Vikings (buckup)
Average: 7.44
Grade: A-

Patriots (Cr122)
Average: 7.44
Grade: A-

Bills (Midswat)
Average: 7.31
Grade: A-

Eagles (roro09)
Average: 7
Grade: B

Giants (RockSlamdance)
Average: 6.95
Grade: B

Dolphins (Sixisbetter)
Average: 6.95
Grade: B

Jaguars (superpunk)
Average: 6.9
Grade: B

Panthers (Cobrakai)
Average: 6.77
Grade: B

Colts (Sheik)
Average: 6.76
Grade: B

Steelers (SteelCurtain)
Average: 6.7
Grade: B

Chiefs (Lazarus_Logan)
Average: 6.7
Grade: B

Buccaneers (Roythedildo)
Average: 6.69
Grade: B

Chargers (VA Cowboy)
Average: 6.65
Grade: B

Redskins (Bangersandmash)
Average: 6.45
Grade: B-

Broncos (Cythim)
Average: 6.2
Grade: C+

Titans (Titanium)
Average: 6.15
Grade: C

Bears (NoShameInMyGame)
Average: 6.09
Grade: C-

Texans (Dbair1967)
Average: 6.05
Grae: C-

Ravens (miked88)
Average: 5.9
Grade: D+

Cardinals (GloryDaysRBack)
Average: 5.87
Grade: D+

Lions (BoneCrusher#31)
Average: 5.82
Grade: D

Bengals (peplaw06)
Average: 5.6
Grade: D-

Saints (ExtremeMcClean)
Average: 5.25
Grade: F

49'ers (EverlastingXXX)
Average: 5.05
Grade: F

cmd34 · Mar 1, 2012

I think I should be recused since I ran the majority of the draft.

I say congrats to DoomsdayDefense!

Thanks again to all of those who participated.

SixisBetter · Mar 1, 2012

Way to go cmd(and/or doomsday),I thought you did well in the draft.
Actually,I thought all involved did fairly well.
I'll take a middle of the pack "B" against this field anyday.
Congrats everyone.

Cr122 · Mar 1, 2012

Congrats, cmd!

Love the way the grading system was presented, guys. Seriously, McShay is better.

A lot of you guys did an excellent job in this. Props.

Midswat · Mar 1, 2012

cmd34 said:
I think I should be recused since I ran the majority of the draft.

I say congrats to DoomsdayDefense!

Thanks again to all of those who participated.

Screw Doomsday. He won the Fantasy league.

You won fair and square.

Besides, the only advantage of running it and participating is you see other peoples lists and you could trade up if needed. Well, outside of the first round for RG3, I don't remember you trading... and most of the assholes who participated failed to send in a value list.

Midswat · Mar 1, 2012

I will say though... for those of you who got a 5 or 6 grade and are pissed about it, there was a lot of harsh grading (imo). Some people didn't give anyone above an 7 or 8.

cmd34 · Mar 1, 2012

Midswat said:
Screw Doomsday. He won the Fantasy league.

You won fair and square.

Besides, the only advantage of running it and participating is you see other peoples lists and you could trade up if needed. Well, outside of the first round for RG3, I don't remember you trading... and most of the assholes who participated failed to send in a value list.

I tried to avoid value lists until that team's pick came up and I refused to trade up except for RG3. As Todd , I knew the Rams weren't going to take him and figured the Vikings weren't either, plus BangersandMash had posted publicly he wasn't interested in trading up. I could have sat there and waited for RG3 to fall to me at 4 but knew it would be much more realistic to trade up.

Janzen Jackson and Akiem Hicks are pet cats of mine, so no one should be shocked I drafted them in the 4th. In fact, had someone drafted them ahead of me, I would have been scrambling since most of my attention was dedicated to running the draft, not the Browns.

cmd34 · Mar 1, 2012

I'm surprised the Bucs grade was as high as it was. He spent his 1st on a defensive lineman despite the real-life Bucs spending 4 high picks on defensive linemen the last 2 years. He was also trading down just for the sake of trading.

As a special bonus, he tried to sabotage the Cowboys vote so that a player he wanted for the Bucs would slip to him a pick later. #Winning.

carphalen5150 · Mar 1, 2012

I knew Smith was a great pick...after the combine and Mayock's public slobbering of his dong he will not fall that far again. I really liked the Chargers, Fins, Chiefs, and Eagles drafts.

carphalen5150 · Mar 1, 2012

cmd34 said:
I'm surprised the Bucs grade was as high as it was. He spent his 1st on a defensive lineman despite the real-life Bucs spending 4 high picks on defensive linemen the last 2 years. He was also trading down just for the sake of trading.

As a special bonus, he tried to sabotage the Cowboys vote so that a player he wanted for the Bucs would slip to him a pick later. #Winning.

I liked the Poe pick. McCoy has not been great and Price has some issues that could keep him from being a fulltime player. Miller was a very solid choice in the 2nd as well.

cmd34 · Mar 1, 2012

carphalen5150 said:
I knew Smith was a great pick...after the combine and Mayock's public slobbering of his dong he will not fall that far again. I really liked the Chargers, Fins, Chiefs, and Eagles drafts.

each pick was BPA from the cbspsortsline board. That GM was a no-show.

Midswat · Mar 1, 2012

cmd34 said:
each pick was BPA from the cbspsortsline board. That GM was a no-show.

Had I realized that, I would've graded differently.

I think your Browns trade set the Rams up perfectly. I really liked the draft that you and Dooms put together.

marionbarberthe4th · Mar 1, 2012

Pound for pound I won

Everyone knows who rg3 is

Cr122 · Mar 1, 2012

The best three drafts were obvious. Browns, Packers, and Jets did a helluva job. cmd deserved the win it was an epic mock.

Also the Rams did very well.

SixisBetter · Mar 1, 2012

MarionBarberThe4th said:
Pound for pound I won

You did on my scorecard.
Taking nothing away from anyone else.
Great mock.

VA Cowboy · Mar 1, 2012

Todd McShay said:
Chargers (VA Cowboy)
Average: 6.65
Grade: B

Midswat · Mar 1, 2012

carphalen5150 · Mar 1, 2012

VA Cowboy said:

I was surprised by your low rating. I thought that draft was outstanding. Great value with every pick.

Midswat · Mar 1, 2012

I thought whoever ran the Bills draft propelled that team to the Super Bowl.

BangersandMash · Mar 1, 2012

I think the Foles pick is what dropped my grade. Other than that I think I had a better draft than a B.

1

Pro Bowler

Anywhere on the line.

Cr122

Guest

2

2

Pro Bowler

Pro Bowler

2

2

Pro Bowler

2

2

Cr122

Guest

Anywhere on the line.

2

2

2

2

Practice Squad